Bagels Are Booming. Does the Business Model Have a Hole in It?
Fresh bagels cooling on a bakery rack during the morning rush 3-minute read
Everyone wants to open a bagel shop right now. The pitch writes itself: flour, water, salt, yeast. How hard can it be?
Ask anyone who has stood in front of a kettle at 4 a.m. wondering whether 40 dozen was the right call.
The growth is real
Jeff's Bagel Run went from its 20th store in August 2025 to 51 locations listed today. PopUp Bagels hit about 30 shops by April 2026 and signed a 300-unit franchise pipeline, with Tiger Global backing it at a $300M valuation. H&H Bagels announced more than 20 locations and over 100 signed franchise agreements in July 2026.
That is real momentum. But note what those numbers measure: signed agreements and store counts. Neither buys breakfast. A returning customer does.
The Crumbl warning
Crumbl grew to 1,101 stores at the end of 2025. Average unit volume fell from $1.35M to $1.139M, down almost 16 percent.
Footprint went up. Store economics went down. Those are two different businesses, and only one of them pays your rent.
Where bagels have the edge
A cookie is a treat. A bagel can be a habit.
Breakfast sandwiches, coffee, office orders, weekend dozens. Multiple reasons to come back, several of them on a Tuesday. Bruegger's marketing director Kate Savelli said the 7 to 11 a.m. window is 60 percent of that chain's business. Circana found morning restaurant traffic rose in early 2025 for the first time since 2023.
Habit beats hype. Habit also means you have to be good at 7 a.m. on a Wednesday in February, which is less fun than a ribbon cutting.
Where it gets expensive
The cheap ingredient is a trap. Flour costs nothing. Labor, throughput, waste and average check decide whether you have a business.
Four numbers that actually matter:
Peak-hour capacity. Three different numbers get confused constantly, so keep them apart:
People on the floor at peak. How many bodies you need standing in the shop at 8:15 a.m.
Labor-hours per day. Every paid hour across the whole day, including the baker who started at 4 a.m. and the closer cleaning at 2 p.m.
People on the roster. How many names you need on the schedule to cover those hours all week.
Now turn that into a roster. Say the shop burns 45 labor-hours a day, which is not 45 people, it's the sum of everyone's shifts: a baker at 6 hours, two sandwich makers at 7 each, a barista at 7, a counter person at 6, a manager at 8, plus a few hours of prep and cleanup.
45 labor-hours a day × 7 days = 315 labor-hours a week. 315 weekly hours ÷ about 30 hours per employee = roughly 11 people on the roster, working managers included, before you cover a single call-out or vacation.
So a shop with 5 people visible at the morning rush still needs about 11 names on the schedule. That gap is where most first-time operators get their labor budget wrong.
The real question isn't how many people to hire. It's how many labor-hours the transactions arriving every 15 minutes actually require.
Production model. Scratch on-site gives you control and a story, and demands skill, equipment and space. Central production with in-store baking gives you consistency and a truck schedule. H&H kettle-boils in New York and bakes on-site. PopUp boils and bakes in-store while making schmears at a commissary, and has said regional production hubs are coming as it scales. All valid. Pick with a spreadsheet, not a feeling.
Daypart honesty. Einstein Bros. reports that 59 percent of surveyed customers say a breakfast sandwich works fine for lunch or dinner. That survey came from its own loyalty community, and saying so is not the same as showing up at 6 p.m. Test weekday commuter breakfast, office catering and weekend family orders separately. Do not underwrite dinner because a survey felt friendly. The $60 loaf says the quiet part out loud
While everyone argues about whether bagels are too cheap, RYE by Martin Auer, an Austrian bakery on Lafayette Street, is selling a 3.3-pound rye sourdough for $60. Half loaf, $30. Quarter, $15. Yes, by the slice.
Four ingredients: rye flour, water, salt, and a family starter that has been alive for more than 50 years. Twenty-four hours of fermentation, 70 minutes in the oven, eight hours of rest before anyone is allowed near it with a knife.
Full disclosure: I'm Austrian. I grew up on that bread. I have also never paid $60 for it.
The internet called it outrageous. I call it an honest invoice. Nobody is paying for flour. They are paying for two days of process, imported grain, skilled hands and Manhattan rent, and the bakery decided to put that on the price tag instead of hiding it.
Bagel shops face the same math and usually resolve it in the opposite direction. The ingredients cost pennies, so the price stays friendly, and the labor, the 4 a.m. start, the kettle and the waste quietly eat the margin.
Cheap ingredients don't make a cheap business. They just make it easier to underprice one.
Pick a lane. Sell a $3.50 bagel and win on throughput, speed and repeat visits. Or sell a $60 loaf and win on craft, story and scarcity. The operators who lose are the ones who price like the first and operate like the second.
What I would tell a client
Make a great bagel. Pour excellent coffee. Keep the menu tight enough that a new hire can run it on day three. Match production to the volume you actually have, not the volume in your deck.
Before you sign a lease, prove four things: repeat visits, average check, peak-hour capacity, and how much product you throw away.
Going viral is optional. Being ready at 7 a.m. is not.
Thinking about opening, buying or fixing a bagel concept? I build the operating model before the lease gets signed: labor-hour schedules, production decisions, peak-hour capacity, and the unit economics that tell you whether store two makes sense.
Let's talk before the ovens arrive.
Comments